Breaking India Indian Muslims Dalits Hate Watch Minorities Law Science & Technology Education
---Advertisement---

‘Where Was Mohammed Siraj?’: India’s NZ Test Selection Draws Criticism From Cricket Veterans

‘Where Was Mohammed Siraj?’: India’s NZ Test Selection Draws Criticism From Cricket Veterans
---Advertisement---

India’s decision to leave Mohammed Siraj out of the playing XI for the first Test against New Zealand has drawn criticism from several former cricketers, including Ravichandran Ashwin, Sunil Gavaskar and Ravi Shastri.

India assistant coach Sitanshu Kotak, however, defended the selection, saying the team management had picked the bowling attack it considered best suited to the conditions at Wellington’s Basin Reserve.

“I personally don’t think it was a wrong decision, no,” Kotak told reporters at the press conference after the first day’s play.

Siraj, who featured in both Tests during India’s tour of Sri Lanka, was left out as India opted for a four-man pace attack comprising Jasprit Bumrah, Akash Deep, Prasidh Krishna and Anshul Kamboj, with Washington Sundar as the spin option.

Asked whether the decision to leave out the experienced pacer was a mistake, Kotak said there was nothing wrong with Siraj and maintained that the selection was based on the conditions and the combination the team wanted.

“There is nothing wrong. I mean I can’t see anything wrong. Like I said, that’s the best possible XI the team management thought it was and that is the one which played,” he said.

Kotak explained that India wanted bowlers who could generate pace, seam movement and swing on a surface with considerable grass. He also said the team had considered how the pitch might behave over all five days rather than focusing only on the opening session.

He defended Kamboj’s pace after questions about the young seamer’s speed dropping during the day, saying he had bowled at around 129 to 130 kmph in his third spell, with a few deliveries clocked at 126 kmph.

Kotak also explained India’s decision to pick Washington ahead of Ravindra Jadeja, pointing to New Zealand’s four left-handed batters in the top order as a reason for preferring an off-spinner.

Ashwin Questions Treatment of Siraj

Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin criticised the team management, saying Siraj’s omission appeared to be part of a pattern that had been developing for weeks.

In a video on his YouTube channel, Ashwin questioned why Siraj had not featured in the preceding ODI matches and suggested that the fast bowler’s place in India’s plans for the 2027 ODI World Cup could also be in doubt.

“Why was an atmosphere created for a week to get Siraj dropped? Not for a week; it’s been built up for a month. First, he wasn’t played in the ODIs. You have an ODI World Cup coming up, and you don’t need Siraj? Tell me, it’s over! How do you not need him? In the ’23 World Cup, he was so strong,” Ashwin said.

He argued that Siraj and Bumrah should be the first two names in India’s pace attack, with the remaining spots decided afterwards.

“Write down Mohammed Siraj and Jasprit Bumrah’s names first, then look for two other seamers. Where is the competition? I don’t understand,” he said.

Gavaskar and Shastri Also Question Selection

Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar said he was surprised by Siraj’s exclusion, arguing that the fast bowler had done little to lose his place in the team.

Speaking to Sony Sports, Gavaskar said Siraj had consistently delivered for India and had not let the team down.

“I don’t think he has let India down. He has never let India down,” he said, adding that he had expected Siraj to play after the pacer featured in the final ODI before the Test series.

Former India head coach Ravi Shastri also questioned the decision in a post on X, pointing to Siraj’s experience, aggression and ability to generate pace and seam movement.

“Hope India bounce back strongly. But if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria, and 140 clicks was hard to come by, one has to ask the question. Where was MOHD SIRAJ? Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball. Surely that counts for something!” Shastri wrote.

Former cricketer and Telangana Minorities Welfare Minister Mohammad Azharuddin also expressed disappointment over Siraj’s omission. He praised the Hyderabad pacer’s performances, particularly when India needed him in Bumrah’s absence, while wishing Kamboj well.

India Recover After New Zealand’s Strong Partnership

India’s bowling attack initially made good use of the conditions, reducing New Zealand to 70 for five after winning the toss and opting to bowl.

However, Henry Nicholls and Glenn Phillips put together an unbeaten 173-run partnership to take the hosts to 243 for five at stumps on the opening day.

Bumrah picked up three of the five wickets, while India’s four seamers shared the workload. Washington conceded 38 runs in 16 overs.

The late recovery left the match evenly poised, with New Zealand having recovered from a difficult position but India still within reach of the lower order when play resumes.

Siraj’s exclusion is likely to remain a talking point, particularly given his experience and record in Test cricket. He has taken 140 wickets in the format and was part of India’s 2023 Asia Cup-winning side, where he was named Player of the Match in the final.

Join WhatsApp

Join Now

Join Telegram

Join Now