The National Christian Council, West Bengal, has objected to remarks by state BJP president Shamik Bhattacharya concerning Christian missionary educational institutions, demanding that he produce evidence of alleged religious conversion activities instead of making generalised accusations against the community.
In a press statement, the Council said remarks by a senior political leader could have serious social and communal consequences, particularly when they cast suspicion on an entire religious community and its educational institutions.
Bhattacharya, who is also a Rajya Sabha member, was challenged to identify the specific schools or colleges facing allegations and make the supporting evidence public to allow an impartial investigation.
“Emotion cannot replace evidence. Allegations cannot replace facts. Political ideology cannot justify placing an entire religious community under suspicion,” the Council said.
Council Defends Christian Educational Institutions
Defending the role of Christian missionary institutions, the Council said their primary purpose was to provide education and promote values such as discipline, compassion and social responsibility, rather than convert students to Christianity.
It pointed out that thousands of students from Hindu, Muslim, Christian and other religious backgrounds study in Christian institutions across the country without being required to give up their religious identities.
“Education must expand the human mind, not erase a person’s religious identity,” the statement said.
The Council clarified that it did not support forced conversion or conversion through fraud, coercion or unlawful inducement. It said any individual or institution found involved in such activities should face an impartial investigation and appropriate legal action.
However, it stressed that religious freedom and the constitutional right to profess and propagate religion should not be equated with forced conversion.
The Council also rejected attempts to portray Christian missionary institutions as instruments of religious conversion, citing the historical presence of Christianity in India. According to Christian tradition, Christianity arrived in the country with St Thomas the Apostle in the first century, long before British colonial rule.
It described attempts to associate Indian Christianity exclusively with British colonialism as historically inaccurate, adding that Indian Christians were an integral part of the country’s social, cultural and national life.
Cites Contributions of Christian Institutions in Bengal
Highlighting the contribution of Christian educational institutions in West Bengal, the Council referred to prominent alumni of Kolkata’s Scottish Church College, including Swami Vivekananda, Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose, Paramahansa Yogananda and A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.
It said these personalities retained their respective religious and philosophical identities while making significant contributions to Indian society, arguing that their association with a Christian institution showed that missionary education did not require students to surrender their beliefs.
The Council warned that generalised allegations against missionary institutions could create fear, mistrust and hostility towards Christians, particularly with Christmas approaching.
Describing Christians as an integral part of West Bengal’s cultural and historical identity, it rejected suggestions that the community was alien to the state.

“We are sons and daughters of this soil. We respect the Constitution of India, honour our national flag and wish to live peacefully alongside every community in this country,” the statement said.
The Council urged the BJP leadership to engage in dialogue and ensure that public discourse was guided by historical understanding, constitutional values and verifiable evidence.
It also called on the state government to protect the educational rights and religious freedom of minorities and ensure that churches, missionary institutions and Christian communities could celebrate Christmas without fear, intimidation or discrimination.
Invoking the teachings of Swami Vivekananda, Sri Chaitanya Mahaprabhu and Rabindranath Tagore, the Council called for religious harmony and mutual respect among communities.
“Our protest is not a sign of weakness. It is a democratic assertion of our dignity, rights and self-respect,” the statement said.






